12/2/16

Another Beautiful, Long Lasting Autumn Makes it Two for Two! Colder Blast Set for Next Week!


Temperatures Autumn 2016

No, it wasn't your imagination - the recent fall was again very nice and one of the warmest across Southeast Lower Michigan. On the whole, Temperatures averaged in the mid 50s this past fall when taking the highs and lows into account across all of Southeast Lower Michigan. Normally, autumns do tend to lean toward the nicer side for weather in these parts - but not this nice nor long lasting! On average; temperatures average around the 50 degree mark in a normal fall but this fall was anything but normal. Temperatures averaged close to 4 1/2 degrees above normal departure /55.4 +4.6/ for all of Southeast Lower Michigan this past fall. This was warm enough to put the region in the top five warmest falls on record at all three cities; Detroit, Flint and Saginaw! That's pretty impressive when you consider this is looking back around a century or more.

And what's more; note I said "again" in the first line. What's even more extraordinary is that this is the second fall in a row that was this nice and warm. Last fall in 2015; temperatures across Southeast Lower Michigan averaged even a bit warmer at 55.9 as opposed to this fall's 55.4! Both Flint and Saginaw averaged slightly warmer last fall while Detroit had its warmer autumn this fall.

Bringing it home; the last time a fall was this warm or warmer was just last fall; a rare feat in itself as there have never been two falls in a row that were this warm over the region. In fact, it's very rare to find any two falls in a row that made even the top 20 warmest listing, let alone top five. There were only two other "back-back" falls at Flint; 1946 /9th/ & 1947 /11th/ and Saginaw with 1930 /19th/ and 1931 /1st/. Detroit had no other back-back warmest falls in the top 20.

Looking at the particular temperature ranking statistics from the last two falls and top 20 warmest


Detroit Area* Flint Bishop** Saginaw Area***
Coldest Warmest Coldest Warmest Coldest Warmest
Temp Year Temp Year Temp Year Temp Year Temp Year Temp Year
 1   46.8 1880   58.4 193146.8 1993  56.5 1931  45.5 1917  57.3 1931
2 46.9 1875 57.6 1881 46.9 1976 55.9 2015 46.2 1972 55.3 2015
3 47.6 1976 57.3 1963 47.0 1981 54.7 1934 46.4 1925 55.0 2016
4 48.0 1876 56.9 2016 47.0 1980 54.2 2016 46.5 1943 54.0 1971
5 48.1 1917 56.6 2015 47.4 1967 53.71971 46.8 1981  53.8 1927
6 48.8 1967  55.8   1946  47.6   1995 53.5  1938 46.8 1976 53.7 1963
7 48.8 1887 55.8 1927 47.8 1997 53.5 1963 46.8 1951 53.2 1998
8 49.1 1980 55.6 2005 47.8 1925 53.5 1927 47.2 1993 52.8 2005
9 49.2 1972 55.5 1961 47.9 1966 53.1 1946 47.2 1980 52.6 2007
10 49.2 1896 55.3 2007 47.9 1943 52.9 2007 47.3 1926 52.6 1920
11 49.4 1907 55.3 1953 48.0 1972 52.9 1947 47.7 1977 52.5 1961
12 49.5 1925 55.3 1941 48.0 1951 52.8 2005 47.8 1992 52.3 1994
13 49.5 1888 55.2 1900 48.1 1996 52.8 1998 48.0 1995 52.2 1975
14 49.7 1974 55.1 1998 48.2 1937 52.7 1975 48.0 1988 52.2 2011
15 49.7 1937 55.1 2011 48.3 1957 52.7 1973 48.1 1952 52.2 1973
16 49.8 1981 55.1 1994 48.5 2006 52.4 1983 48.2 1989 52.2 1946
17 49.9 1895 54.8 1922 48.5 1959 52.4 1961 48.2 1986 52.1 1941
18 50.0 1889 54.8 1920 48.7 1952 52.4 2011 48.2 1959 52.1 1970
19 50.1 1996 54.6 2004 48.8 1992 52.4 1941 48.3 1991 52.1 1930
20 50.1 1943 54.6 1882 48.8 1962 52.3 1953 48.4 1967 52.0 1934
* Detroit Area temperature records date back to November 1874.
** Flint Bishop temperature records date back to January 1921.
*** Saginaw Area temperature records date back to January 1912.

Rainfall Autumn 2016

Rainfall averaged above normal /11.36", +2.78"/ around the Detroit area but that was exclusively due to a wet September with over six inches of rain. Near normal rain was registered at Flint /9.68", +0.71"/ and below average in the Saginaw Valley /7.45",-1.71'/. This coming after a rather dry summer with a pick up in rainfall later in the summer into the early fall.

Looking ahead for the first half of December 

The first several days of December look to be about average with a plunge into colder, below normal temperatures the middle of next week /6-7th/. This will be the coldest air of the season being quite abrupt and noticeable considering the past fall. Look for temperatures to average near to slightly above normal through Tuesday with the decidedly colder weather, thereafter. Average highs for the first week of December are in the upper 30s to lower 40s with lows in the mid 20s across all Southeast Lower Michigan..

After the Polar front moves through by Wednesday; highs will drop off in the upper 20s to lower 30s with lows into the teens to lower 20s much of the remainder of the week. Best chances for precipitation will be snow or rain/snow on Sunday-Sunday night and rain to snow showers Tuesday into Wednesday. Those traveling near and downwind of the Great Lakes should keep abreast for  Lake effect snow forecasts mid-week on, next week.

 

 Making weather fun while we all learn, 

Bill Deedler - SEMI_WeatherHistorian

 


11/20/16

Will La Nina Really Be An Important Factor This Winter? Winter 2016-17 Outlook


Local Data Suggests

TemperaturesNormal to Above


Expect temperatures during the 2016-2017 winter to be more variable than usual with conflicting data in research. This will be due to a variable upper wind jet stream. I look for both a split flow and phasing of jets as much over the Central and Western US as in the East. Guidance and Analogues suggest the heart of the winter /Jan-Feb/ seeing the most of the action (though that doesn't mean there won't be any, other times) but winters tended to start somewhat later than average (see more in Analogues). This will be guided by the anticipated weak La Nina to Neutral state interacting with the North Atlantic and subset Arctic Oscillation /NAO, AO/. Just as important this winter will be the Pacific Decadal Oscillation /PDO/ and associated Eastern Pacific Oscillation /EPO/.

In the final analysis, I look for the Southeast Lower Michigan winter to average around normal to above normal.  Temperature departures should average from -1.0F to + 2.0F.

Actually, expanding on this “normal” idea, it is interesting to note that the 100 year winter mean temperature for Detroit is approximately 26.7 degrees with a one standard deviation spread of 3.5 degrees either side of that 26.7. Statistically speaking, based on this data the temperatures could average as low 23.2 degrees or as high as 30.2 and still be considered within a “normal” range of the 100 year mean. The 30 year mean at Detroit has risen appreciably over earlier averages, mainly due to the local urban heat island. That winter average /1981-2010/ now rests at 27.9, a full degree /1.2/ above the old 100 year.

This outlook hinges mainly on the endurance of the Pacific jet and its extensive eastward push and its interaction with the polar and Arctic jets. Normally during La Nina, the more dominant jet is the polar and/or Arctic jet leading to colder than normal temperatures. However, I feel this winter will see more interaction with the Pacific jet stream jet, a lay-over of sorts, if you will, from El Nino and the warm PDO (discussed at length, below). These variables, combined at times with the Polar Vortex over central and western Canada, supports this variable forecast. I see this hindering the dominance of below normal temperatures this winter. More on the jet structures in the storm track section.

Snowfall and Rainfall Normal to Above depending on location 

Because of the temperature variability and associated storm tracks observed in many of the analogue winters, snowfall in those winters ranged widely from above normal to below. This would be expected since the variance of temperatures hint at the variability of the upper atmospheric patterns and storm tracks. Therefore, pinpointing the perceived prevailing storm tracks this winter will make a significant difference in regard to seasonal snowfall. 

Using the expected dominant storm tracks for the upcoming winter, it is likely much of the region will experience normal to above normal precipitation with above normal snowfall /5.0"+/ around Detroit's northern and western suburbs north into the Flint and Saginaw Valley; to around normal /within 5.0"/ over the far Southeast corner of Lower Michigan (south of Detroit). Mixed precipitation events seem to be a higher than normal risk.

Broad Scale Discussion 

 

An interesting and another challenging winter is ahead with three main climate and weather drivers, a generally weak La Nina to Neutral conditions, the illusive NAO and PDO, working together to bring Southeast Lower Michigan a fairly interesting winter. 

1 - La Nina 

The difference between the current developing La Nina to the last La Nina is the strength and timing. The last La Nina was very strong compared to the current developing La Nina's strength.


                                              Current Developing La Nina as early November




                                             
                              Past La Nina stage as of November 2010
                                       


The strength of the previous La Nina 2010-11 is quite evident by the below normal SST's dipping to -2.0C as opposed this winter's expected ~ -.7C  to -1.1C                                              


                                                        October 2016 Average SST's







Multivariate ENSO Index 1950 - early 2016 shows up to the strong El Nino of the past year and note the strong La Nina during the Winter of 2010-11.






The Southern Oscillation Index /SOI/ below shows well the recent negative corresponding values in conjunction to our recent strong El Nino. Remember; an above normal SST is reflective of a negative SOI.




Latest Modeling Projections of the expected weak La Nina to Neutral conditions







Corresponding Analogue Years by SOI values (positive = La Nina)  

 (only numerical values for the first two analogues available)



        SOI 1878-79
1878  4    -8.2  1
1878  5     2.5  4
1878  6    -3.2  5
1878  7    14.8  4
1878  8    12.4  2
1878  9    17.5  2
1878  10   11.7  2
1878  11   14.4  2
1878  12   16.6  2
1879  1    12.1  2
1879  2    14.1  2
1879  3    10.8  2
1879  4    10.9  2
 
   
 SOI 1889-90 
1889  4    -0.8  4
1889  5    -1.2  5
1889  6    18.4  4
1889  7     1.4  3
1889  8     2.1  5
1889  9    11.1  4
1889  10    4.7  2
1889  11   22.0  4
1889  12   20.7  2
1890  1    20.3  2
1890  2    10.6  2
1890  3    11.8  2
1890  4     5.7  2
 
Available SOI Graphs below from analogues years reflect Neutral to Moderate
La Ninas after strong El Ninos. 








Latest SOI data through October shows a Neutral to weak La Nina state


 

2-Pacific Decadal Oscillation /PDO/ and associated subset EPO

The Pacific Decadal Oscillation remains in the recently switched warm phase, changing over a year ago. A warm phase of the PDO is represented on the left of the following example and compare it to the current state.


                             Warm Phase of the PDO                    Cool Phase of the PDO


Current Warm Phase of the PDO and weak La Nina show well in this recent SST scan on November 6th, 2016. Generally warm phases coincide with El Nino's or Neutral states and rarely La Nina states. It does happen and we have two winters in the current analogues when such an occurrence happened like the present time (and their subsequent winters were our coldest). Studies propose that when the PDO and ENSO are out of phase; which is a somewhat a rare event, that they may cancel out their known effects. Keep this in mind when looking at the Analogues. 


"The Pacific Decadal Oscillation (PDO) is a pattern of Pacific climate variability similar to ENSO in character, but which varies over a much longer time scale. The PDO can remain in the same phase for 20 to 30 years, while ENSO cycles typically only last 6 to 18 months. The PDO, like ENSO, consists of a warm and cool phase which alters upper level atmospheric winds. Shifts in the PDO phase can have significant implications for global climate, affecting Pacific and Atlantic hurricane activity, droughts and flooding around the Pacific basin, the productivity of marine ecosystems, and global land temperature patterns. Experts also believe the PDO can intensify or diminish the impacts of ENSO according to its phase. If both ENSO and the PDO are in the same phase, it is believed that El NiƱo/La Nina impacts may be magnified. Conversely, if ENSO and the PDO are out of phase, it has been proposed that they may offset one another, preventing "true" ENSO impacts from occurring".



"Odd-ball" Pacific SST Analogue Winters

There were only two winters in this winter's outlook research that contained a warm state PDO while the La Nina developed and prevailed; the Winter of 1878-79 and 1983-84. The 1878-79 La Nina winter was fairly weak while the 1983-84 La Nina winter was a bit more developed. Curiously, those two winters were our coldest in this season's analogues.





3-North Atlantic/Arctic Oscillation /NAO & AO/


One of the most important players for winter's outcome and ingredients in this winter’s weather is the trend of the North Atlantic Oscillation/Arctic Oscillation (NAO/AO). This is the biggest challenge to the forecast and potentially has the biggest bust potential. While trends with La Ninas and El Ninos are relatively stable, the NAO is highly elusive and trends are seen only a week or two in advance. Generally, colder winters in the study occurred with a predominately negative NAO. Below is a graph of the NAO in its positive and negative phases with arrows denoting the analogue years in in this winter's study.





Projections of this winter's NAO/AO are variable. One scientist who bases NAO/AO trend expectations and subsequent winter temperatures, Judah Cohen , strongly bases the winter temperature projection on early snowfall across Eurasia along with sea ice coverage in the early Autumn. His research has shown that these variables affect the NAO/AO development and positioning.. At this time with higher than normal snowfall coverage in that area and weaker ice formation in the Arctic this fall, projections are for a colder winter for almost all of the eastern U.S (excepting New England). Mr. Cohen has a nice update here every week or so on current and expected trends.



4-Solar cycle 

Solar cycle actual effects on short term weather and longer term climate variability remain a controversial subject. I've read several articles which support or are against their shorter term winter relevancy. Some theorize that both natural solar cycles and man's influence affect our climate. I am in favor of the solar cycle being somewhat relevant and sometimes giving the present winter cycle a "little kick" in regard to hemispheric wind flow patterns and resulting temperatures.  Studies out of Europe for example, do in fact make the connection to wintertime effects.


"The Euro–Atlantic sector seems to be a region with a par-
    ticularly strong solar influence on the troposphere. In fact,
                               significant positive correlations between solar activity and
    surface temperature in Europe have been reported in several
                                papers (e.g. Tung and Camp, 2008; Lean and Rind, 2008;
                                Lockwood et al., 2010; Woollings et al., 2010), although
                                 long records tend to give very weak signals (van Olden-
     borgh et al., 2013). We found a weak but significant change
     in the mean late winter circulation over Europe, which re-
     sults in detectable impacts on the near-surface climate. Fig-
     ure 9 suggests that during solar minima more cold air is ad-
     vected from the Arctic, thus resulting in a slightly increased
                                probability of colder winters for large parts of the conti-
     nent. Sirocko et al. (2012) recently reached the same con-
                                clusion after analysing 140 yr in 20CR, although their re-
                                sults are strongly dependent on their selection criteria for
       the solar minimum composite (van Oldenborgh et al., 2013),
                                   which includes only one winter for each solar cycle".


Comparing solar cycles of the past analogue winters to the present as a possible influence only and not a major contributor. While the solar cycle was in various modes, the tendency is for these La Nina's to Neutral winters to occur during the mid to lower part of the cycle or during an overall, weaker cycle (like the one we have entered, below).




The closest previous solar cycles (strength and positioning) during the analogue winters to this upcoming winter occurred in; the winter's of 1897-98, 1973-74, 2007-08 (averaged normal temperatures). Besides those winters, the winters that also occurred during the decline but near or at the lull of the solar cycle (like next winter, 2017-18 for example) are; 1878-79, 1889-90, 1964-65 and 2010-11. Therefore, we have seven (out of 11) analogue winters in the study that were near this winter's expected solar cycle positioning. The winter of 1998-99 was near the same positioning but was during the incline.


Here we see the latest solar cycle amplitude compared to the previous cycles back to the mid 1970s.


Winter 2016-17 Analogues

(click on table to enlarge)


Analogue Research and Results

As stated above, the analogue years were quite variable but with a tendency toward below normal temperatures. Remember, looking at Detroit alone, you run into the influenced heat island normals, which then would tend to skew the averages below normal slightly, since they are warmer (than the 100 year) - get it? Anyway, all three cities suggest a normal winter when the variances are averaged. Looking at the individual winters, there still remains a preference for a below normal winter. Winter's were most active mid to late winter, with the highest snowfalls mid winter. Looking at December's alone; suggests that the winters (notable snows) started generally mid to late month, somewhat later than average. Back to the entire winter; the second preference was for a normal winter and the least was for an above normal. This certainly fits La Nina winters but we are not dealing with just a La Nina winter. The analogues represent quite a range Neutral to moderate La Ninas and still I was only able to find 11 that match the past strong El Nino melding into a Neutral to moderate La Nina by the next winter season.

Even with the dominant normal to below normal winters; there were a decent showing of above normal winters, enough to pull the averages back to near normal. As mentioned above, the coldest winters were found when the rare warm PDO existed above the cool La Nina, as in this present year. Studies have found this tends to dampen the effects of the La Nina.



The split in the temperature pattern (above normal Southeast to below North) is well displayed during the analogue years




In addition with the conflicting and variable types of air masses in the same location, note heavier precipitation in the battle zone below.





 

Winter 2016-17 Upper Wind Anomalies & Projected Storm Tracks


Compare the typical jet structure of the La Nina below with the analogue years depicted jet and anomalies in the following section:

 


 

The upper wind anomaly pattern from all analogue winters shows a marked difference in jet preferences and placing upper Lows and ridging when compared to a typical La Nina pattern. While the semi-permanent eastern Canadian Low is represented by the lobe of negative anomalies south of Hudson & James Bays; the most predominate departures in the upper wind anomalies materialized over western Canada and the Northwestern US. It's almost like the typical La Nina upper wind trough pattern shifts back west at times and creates the negative departures over that region. Referring to the typical La Nina map (above), the ridging is dominant on the West Coast of Canada and to a lesser extent, the US which would negate the coldest of winters.



The mean (an average) upper wind flow for the analogue years is shown below but nevertheless, still intimates weak troughing from the Aleutian Low south-southeast to the Desert Southwest. This suggests the phasing of the upper low impulses dropping southeast from Alaska and western Canada and thus, giving  "birth" to a more pronounced western US trough at times. Again, this extended troughing from western Canada and into the US is displayed nicely by the analogue composite anomaly map, above. 

 Resulting Storm Tracks This Winter


Main upper air feature positions along with generated storm tracks by my analysis per analogue data is on the map below. The upper lows and troughs are depicted in black; while the resulting storm tracks are in red. As you can see, the generated storm tracks to our southwest are mainly Kansas and Texas Panhandle Lows which have a tendency to track near or over Southeast Lower Michigan. If the impulse generated is far enough south, some Arkansas or even Louisiana lows are possible but they are not expected to be a main player this winter. East Coast storms should be more the result of Ohio Valley and mid Atlantic phasing.




What do the models have to say about the winter? Mild to warm everywhere if you look as of November 2016




 

For December

NMME                                                                                               IMME








Prob fcst
PAC calib. prob fcst
NCEP_CFSv2
CMC1_CanCM3
CMC2_CanCM4
            GFDL_FLOR 
 
GFDL_CM2.1
NCAR_CCSM4
NASA_GEOS5
NCAR_CESM IMME













 




Forecasted precipitation trends for the winter generally follow the analogue years trend



NMME


Prob fcst
PAC calib. prob fcst
NCEP_CFSv2
CMC1_CanCM3
CMC2_CanCM4
GFDL_FLOR

GFDL_CM2.1
NCAR_CCSM4
NASA_GEOS5
NCAR_CESM



IMME
 

I'll be back at times when notable storms and/or temperature changes are expected to affect the region along with other historic storm information for the winter!

Making weather fun while we all learn,
Bill Deedler - SEMI_WeatherHistorian